How To Sell or Trade Your Magic: The Gathering Cards or Collection

Have extra Magic: The Gathering cards that you’re looking to turn into cash or store credit? Star City Games offers individual sellers and store owners a variety of options to ensure that doing so is as easy and convenient as possible!

If you have any additional questions about selling or trading your Magic: The Gathering cards to us, please click on the corresponding button below, or email us and we’ll be happy to assist you.


If you are wanting to sell your cards individually by mail

  • 30% Store Credit Bonus
  • Itemized card listings with prices
  • Fast turnaround
Sell with Buylist


If you are wanting to sell your collection or a larger assortment of cards by mail without needing to do so individually

  • Ship your cards to us
  • Receive an offer
  • We pay return shipping costs if not accepted
Get started with Ship + Sell


If you are wanting to sell individual cards or an entire collection in person at our Star City Game Center in Roanoke, Virginia

  • At your convenience
  • In-person transaction
  • Immediate payment
Make a Game Center Appointment


If you want to sell an entire store inventory, a large amount of bulk, or a sizeable collection:

Available in Delaware, Kentucky, Maryland, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, Washington DC, and West Virginia.

Schedule a visit